My time is up, and I'm back in Australia.
Oh how my Gap Year went by so quickly. I'm so happy and grateful for the experiences that I've gained (medical and non-medical) during this period, even though I haven't documented it fully on this blog. I need to finish off the remaining East Timor Medical Elective entries when I have spare time.
Medicine in Australia is excellent for a first career, and I'm not ashamed to be a doctor anymore. At the end of the day it's just a job, and whilst the Medical Profession continues to be devalued/degraded by the powers that be, I still have many skills and experiences to gain from working as a doctor for a few years, before potentially moving on to whatever I find more intellectually stimulating and/or higher paying. For now, Medicine is my back-up job. I will try to cherish any positive moments that occur with my "heart".
I've finished the internship orientation, but tomorrow will be my 1st day of work.
Here's to hoping things will go well, I have to bite the bullet and start full-time work for real. Need to take things one day at a time and learn things by osmosis.
Fingers crossed...
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Friday, December 19, 2014
East Timor Medical Elective - Week 4 (Part 6 / 6)
“HORACIO” (PARKINSON'S DISEASE)
After Dr. Dan did his gratitude speech
thanking the Patients etc (followed by loud applause), it was meal-time. After
eating a bit, I was told that a Patient arrived (very late) to see Dr. Dan. I
was curious to see the Patient and find out why he came so late.
Sitting on the bench, where the ceremony
was held less than an hour ago, was a frail old man called “Horacio”,
hunched forward, with a resting tremor in both of his hands. His son
accompanied him.
Spot Diagnosis: Parkinson's Disease.
I asked Horacio's son what has happened,
and he said that his Father has been walking weak and shaking like this for
nearly a year now. “Why are his arms and legs weak?” he asked.
I told him that I suspected it was a
Neurological Condition called Parkinson's Disease, that affects your movement,
but he was confused, saying “The sickness is with his limbs and not his brain.”
I explained that some Brain Conditions can impair movement, and asked if I
could examine Horacio.
Horacio's arms were having a tremor. I
shook his hand and moved his arms about. They were stiff with Cogwheel
Rigidity, which further supported my thoughts. He also had the same Flat Affect
as me, and I asked his son whether he smiles these days, in which he said no.
Dr. Dan came to meet him and also gave the
same spot diagnosis, and arranged for him to have a script for Levodopa /
Carbidopa. Unfortunately the Pharmacy ran out of this, and I became desperate.
“What about Pramipexole or Ropinirole?” I asked the Pharmacist. Nope, they
didn't have those either.
I felt sorry for Horacio, and wished that
if I were in his position in the future, that somebody would try to get the
medication for me. Being at a higher hypothetical risk of Parkinson's Disease
(or Fronto-Temporal Lobe Dementia) later on in life, this patient triggered a
“soft part” in my heart. I wanted him to start the medication and experience
its benefits.
I wanted to demonstrate the degree of
concern that I'd wish for someone to have towards me if I had it. I didn't want
to perpetuate or feel abandoned. So I offered Dr. Dan to go to a Pharmacy and
buy the medication using my own money if it was available. I told the Patient
and his son to wait for 30 minutes whilst I ran out with my bag huffing and
puffing.
A few hundred metres down the road from the
Clinic, a man in a motorcycle came up to me, and asked if I wanted a lift. I
asked him who he was, in which he claimed he was Horacio's son's friend “Vincent”,
who was observing me the entire time.
Having only ridden a motorcycle once before
as a child, I was quite reticent to accept his offer, but due to my perceived
“urgency” of the issue at the time (being in “Adrenaline Mode”), agreed to do
so. The helmet barely fit my head, and I couldn't fasten the helmet belt under
my chin, but I thought “Whatever” and let it be.
I made sure my backpack was fully zipped
up, but my other handbag couldn't be closed, so I quickly tucked the items to
the bottom lest it fall out during the ride. As I sat on the motorcycle,
Vincent told me to grab onto his shoulders tightly.
I grabbed onto him for “dear life”, and as
the motorcycle started going ahead, I gripped him even harder. The breeze/wind
was sweeping past my arms, and my heart was beating fast. I was freaking out
inside due to the state of Dili's traffic and the fact that I wasn't wearing
any other protective gear, but strangely was able to look flat on the outside,
and to some extent even exhilarated. He could tell that I had very little
experience riding motorcycles, in which I soon admitted to him. I was
simultaneously horrified yet excited at this “motorcycle adventure”.
He dropped me off at each of the 4 nearby
pharmacies. As I entered each pharmacy, I quickly rattled out my spiel in Tetum
to the staff about needing Levodopa/Carbidopa for Horacio, hoping that I'd “hit
the jackpot”. I started feeling doubtful inside when the pharmacy assistants
had puzzled looks on their faces, claiming to have never heard of these
medications before, or even Parkinson's Disease. I initially thought they were
stupid, but gave them the benefit of the doubt and mentioned that it was a
neurological condition that makes the patient have difficulty walking and
moving their arms etc, and one of them thought I was thinking of Stroke. When I
mentioned “neurological condition”, or more specificially “brain disease”
(moras kakutak), one of them thought I was referring to a Psychiatric Condition
instead. Another assistant offered to sell me Methyldopa because it had the
same suffix (-dopa), but I rejected that, explaining that it was a completely
different drug for a completely different condition (Hypertension).
Each rejection from a pharmacy made me more
disappointed, and as it came close to 7 PM, I knew it was time to give up. The
Adrenaline and hopeful suspense from the motorcycle rides between the
pharmacies ended, and I felt very disillusioned, having turned out empty handed
from these attempts. I wanted Horacio to have the medication so badly, so I
would hate to tell him in his face that the pharmacies didn't offer it.
As I returned to the Clinic, it surprised
me that Horacio and his son weren't there anymore, although to be honest I was
a bit relieved coz I was spared having to break the bad news to them. Vincent
said that he'd inform them instead that I couldn't find the medication. I
thanked him very much for the rides.
I told Dr. Dan about my failure, and
started walking home in the dark feeling quite upset and frustrated about this
fruitless venture. I started pondering why the Pharmacy staff were seemingly
ignorant, but it became clearer to me. Pharmacies, like with nearly all other
private healthcare facilities, function as businesses. They will sell the
medications that are profitable and are in higher demand. Because East Timor's
population is very young with the mean life expectancy at ~65 years, the
prevalence of Neurodegenerative Conditions such as Parkinson's and Alzheimer's
Disease etc would be much lower than in Australia. Low demand for a
low-prevalence condition would mean that the Pharmacies are much less likely to
stock it. Out of principle, this is fair from a financial point of view
(“Capitalism”, “Supply and Demand”), but I felt really sorry for Horacio and
all other East Timorese patients with low-prevalence conditions who wouldn't be
catered for when the time called for it. The Public Healthcare System may
provide medications for these people, but unfortunately are also unreliable and
have frequent shortages due to incredibly meagre budgets.
After this realization, I stopped feeling
guilty because I knew I tried my best at the time and wouldn't be able to
rectify the situation any other way in that short time period.
My sadness toned down as I internally
gloated on this intense experience. In Australia, had a patient been diagnosed
with Parkinson's Disease, they'd simply receive a script and obtain it from any
bread-and-butter pharmacy, try the medication and see a GP/Specialist for
follow-up, end-of-story.
But the healthcare situation in East Timor
allowed me to take a much more “colourful” route.
My desire to obtain the medication
temporarily overrided my fear of riding motorcycles, especially in a city with
very dangerous traffic like Dili. I was told to avoid riding Microlets because
they were dangerous, yet I managed to ride a motorcycle here, and from a
stranger!!!
I couldn't believe that the encounter with
Horacio, the motorcycle rides to the pharmacies, and the return trip, all
occurred in ~ 30 minutes. I checked my handbag and nothing fell out thankfully.
Most importantly, I felt so grateful and
lucky that I was physically unscathed.
Omg what an adventurous end to the week...
Sunday, October 19, 2014
East Timor Medical Elective - Week 4 (Part 5 / 6)
BPC'S 15TH ANNIVERSARY
Friday afternoon was BPC's 15th
Anniversary. It was amusing that Dr. Dan's Birthday was quite close
to BPC's “Birthday”, and I asked a staff member if both have ever
been celebrated together, in which she said “Yes, in fact most of
the time!”
| Cake for BPC's 15th Anniversary. The icing design is based on BPC's logo. Middle symbol is supposed to be a Crocodile, from the traditional East Timorese Legend of "La Faek". |
The front door to the main building
was covered with cloth / curtains, and a clothed table set up for the
ceremony. The arrangement was simple yet pretty. I sat at the side of
the main waiting benches. I felt like something big was going to
happen.
The crowds gathered, and eventually
the Padre/Priest showed up in his gown, starting his sermon. I was
unable to understand all of it, but clearly he was quoting from the
Bible and at some point discussing the “Catholic values” of love
etc, and linking it with Dr. Dan's charity work. There was a bit I
disagreed with however, when he followed the discussion of medical
work by stating “La iha sakrifisiu, la iha hadomi.” ( “[If]
there's no sacrifice, there's no love.”)
***WARNING – RANT, NOT DIRECTLY
RELATED TO THE ANNIVERSARY***
For about a minute, I got really
annoyed when he said that, because he somehow implied that Medicine
as a Career was a “Calling”, that one must give it their all-in
to their work as a Dr. At the time it felt extremely “traditional”.
My observations are that as the Medical Profession in Australia (and
several other Western countries, especially the Anglophone ones) has
become significantly devalued and disrespected compared to the “good
old days” (30+ years ago). It's gotten to the point that the notion
of introducing a $7 co-payment for visiting a GP (in spite of the 9+
years of study/training to be an independent GP) is seen by the
voting majority as so “unaffordable” (in spite of the copious
social welfare relative to other countries), even though they happily
fork out (much) more for Hairdressers and Restaurant Meals.
These days in Australia at least,
being a Dr is for the most part just a job rather than some “G-dly
pursuit/passion” that “should” take over your entire life for
the sake of saving humanity, irregardless of the pay. Even in the
face of increasingly onerous (and possibly unjust) Medico-Legal
Pressure/Stress, Public Hospital salaries for Drs continue to decline
in real terms every few years through an apparently fractured Dr'
Union, in addition to exploitation by State Governments. This is in
contrast to the Nurses who in practice hold more clout despite their
graduate and junior nurse oversupply being far far worse.
We're human as well, and have our own
personal, financial needs etc. I resent it when a lot of people
(Australian or not) think that just because we're working as Doctors,
that money should never be an issue. They expect Doctors to work and
behave like Saints/Monks, yet for the most part in Australia they're
not treated as such (as opposed to Developing Countries).
Interestingly, a lot of these people have far more sympathetic views
towards Nurses. Medicine is a highly trained profession, with a lot
of responsibilities, impacting on Patient's lives every day. One
mistake can kill a Patient. My opinion is that the remuneration
should reflect that, otherwise at the very least the working
conditions should be conducive for focusing on Clinical Work.
Drs in Developing Countries have much
lower pay, but at least they don't have to worry about getting sued
or notified regularly. They can just focus on Clinical Work and try
their best to treat Patients with the limited resources available, ie
“Classical Medicine”. With Medico-Legal repercussions being so
strong in Australia (closely following America), I think it's gotten
to the point where if Drs' real pay continues to fall, retention
within the Public System will decrease as more Drs feel the pay isn't
worth the responsibilities and stress of covering their “Professional
Asses” for half the day, lest they miss something and get penalized
over some dubious technicality by some judge who happens to have
negligible Clinical Insight by comparison (and just follows the fine
print created by other similarly clueless politicians/senior bureaucrats etc).
Some people try to dismiss the issue
of (Public) Drs' pay, purely attributing it as a product of Supply vs
Demand, but the fact that the vast majority of Junior Doctors and
(Non-GP) Registrars are stuck within the Public System means that
State Governments can exploit their Monopsony (as much as possible)
on such highly-skilled labour, undermining these Drs' true value
compared to a genuinely free market (hypothetical). How else could
you make an Intern “only” earn ~$32/hr after studying for 5-7+
years at Uni, when a School-Leaver can already earn ~$24/hr as a
Waitress in a suburban Cafe, even though for the latter job the entry
requirements are vastly lower, and labour supply vastly greater?
These Nay-Sayers can try to dismiss
the issue of Australian Drs' pay/conditions in light of the current
climate, but at the end of the day, Drs can and will vote with their
feet if needed (as demonstrated by the Queensland Health debacle
earlier this year)...
***RANT OVER***
After the sermon, the choir started
singing songs. Again I only understood part of it, but I started
feeling a lump in my throat. Some of the choir people, and audience
started shedding tears and sniffled during the singing.
I started feeling strange. Initially I
felt a tingling sensation in my skin, with my “hairs standing
straight”, as I absorbed the magnanimous blend of melody and
harmonies. By the time they reached the Portuguese Hymn “Ao
Amor que te Arrasta”, my throat became tight, and I felt like I
was about to cry, and had to restrain myself from doing so. I stopped
looking at the Choir singing, and just stared at the lyrics, and
intermittently closing my eyes, but it didn't help much.
I couldn't understand why I started
having such a strong automatic reaction, like I was being possessed
by an unknown being. I felt like I was subconsciously being commanded
to remove my Flat Affect, and cry. It was only a few minutes after I
got annoyed at that specific sentence from the Padre/Priest, and I
was surprised at how quickly my feelings changed. I didn't like how
my body was being pushed to do something that I intellectually
thought was irrational, and didn't want to give into “Emotional
Conformity”, yet another part of me felt that to cry was the
correct emotion to display during this period. I previously never
entered into my “Social Database” to cry during Hymn singing,
especially when we sang Hymns routinely at Assembly in High School.
Back then, we had Assemblies 3 times / week, so it would've been
ridiculous for me to cry that frequently. I felt like I was being
overwhelmed emotionally, to the point of being nauseous.
I wanted to leave the place coz I felt
overloaded, but thought it would be rude if I left early on such a
large occasion. I just sat and decided to let the music “penetrate”
me, hoping that my body would quickly down-regulate the seemingly
visceral response. Eventually it did, but only near the end.
I didn't cry at the end, but as the
nausea disappeared, I could “observe” the warmth and passion
shown by the Choir, in fact the East Timorese people at the ceremony.
I personally hated conformity in its own right, but I could now see
how pleasing it was to have people gathered at a place for
celebration. Some of the piety was visible; Patients with TB or
suspected TB sat in the audience and took off their face-masks as a
sign of respect. Everybody's presence at the time just felt
“beautiful”, but I was unable to quantify it. Some of the
Patients who complained of Pain earlier in the day, looked much
livelier and in less visible pain as well. The arrangement just “felt
right”.
![]() |
| Priest/Padre is feeding round wafers to a long line of people. |
Ever since migrating to Australia, I
had an “inside feeling” that in spite of its relative wealth,
there was something missing that other poorer countries (or even
America) had. I had access to food, clean tap water, and a home
connected to electricity, adequate sanitation, in addition to my
direct Family. Yet when I went out in Melbourne, I frequently felt
the outer environment was rather “Bland” and “Soul-less”,
especially the suburbs. I thought that there was something “off”
or “Artificial”. I thought I was being spoiled or ungrateful for
having such sentiments in a Developed Country. Yet in Dili, a City of
~200,000 people (as opposed to Melbourne's ~4 Million), with far less
public amenities, I felt much more stimulated outside of home, and
not in the anxious sense.
It must be the people and their
collective behaviour, I thought. Their population is less
Multicultural (in spite of the other Tribal languages in the
Districts) than Australia, and the people have far less opportunities
Education and Vocation-wise. The weather is becoming hotter, but the
people on the whole behave quite “warmly” in spite of the
Language Barrier. I don't feel Euphoric here, but have been
appreciating the more “visible” homogeneity in behaviour from the
locals – their responses, questions, opinions, gratitude (is
gratitude more from being poor, or Catholic influence?), “warmth”.
Nearly all the locals I speak to are eager to learn new things and/or
help develop the country, even if they are unable to think of
specific solutions. National development is an obvious goal that
unites people. Their word for development, “Dezenvolvimentu”
is used copiously in TV and Newspapers. Many people are poor, and
Youth Unemployment is high, but they just keep moving on, day by day.
The conformity was easier for me to
process thanks to my fondness for repetition, and I felt great joy at
being able to understand East Timorese people as a whole a lot
quicker than Australians, without being considered “superficial”,
“naive”, or “lacking insight”. It pleased me to be able to
rapidly understand the psyche of NT people from another country
despite my initial deficits secondary to the AS. The paradoxical
stimulation from the East Timorese people's superficial
simplicity/purity still baffled me (at the time of this writing).
However at the very end of the day I
wouldn't want “Mass” conformity to happen in Australia. I think I
was in the position to be able to be fussy over the presence of an
obvious “Culture” or not. In the long-term, I value my freedom to
be un-chained to an overarching Religion (Catholicism), or
Collectivistic Society (as per traditional East Timorese Culture)
where there is pressure to get married and have children, along with
much more influence from relatives (non-parents) in various issues.
The taxes are much higher in Australia and there are a lot more
lazy/ungrateful Bogans and Politicians, but in spite of the
over-regulation and bureaucracy, I still have many more opportunities
to pursue what I want vocationally and academically here than in East
Timor, in addition to access to a far more robust Healthcare System
(Public and Private).
It's probably unfair to compare with a
Developing Country, but many things aren't set in stone. In the
future, if my values change, and if I manage to save up enough money,
I always have the option to explore/move to other countries (even
East Timor?!) if I get fed up with life in Australia later on.
Australia seems to lack an overarching “Culture” and is
geographically isolated, but the price for this relative
Individualism (along with wealth) is that you have to put in much
more effort to find others with similar interests, beliefs and goals,
eg Subcultures or Hobby Groups. Otherwise you can just resort to the
internet. You can't have your cake and eat it. 1st World
Problems indeed. At least I don't have to truly worry about starving
to death, or despair at a hospital being short of a common
Antibiotic, any time of the year.
East Timor Medical Elective - Week 4 (Part 4 / 6)
“MATEUS” (APPENDICITIS)
I clerked “Mateus” in
another afternoon (this time on medication) with Natalya and another
student watching me, but apparently he was waiting for nearly ~6
hours since being admitted this morning. I didn't recall seeing him
in the morning Ward Rounds, so he probably arrived just after we left
the Baixa (Gen Med) ward.
I looked at Dr. Dan's mini-notes: “RLQ
pain - ?Appendicitis ?Ascaris”.
Oooooh, a potential Appendicitis case,
I thought.
I asked Mateus what his problem was,
and he said that he's been having pain that started in the RLQ last
night, and later spread towards his RUQ and Epigastric area.
It sounded strange. I recalled the
textbooks stating that Appendicitis initially starts in the centre of
the Abdomen (around the belly button), and then migrates towards the
RLQ, and then causes diffuse Peritonitis if not treated fast enough.
Mateus' abdominal pain didn't sound like the textbook, but I was
still worried.
After asking enough questions about
his Abdo pain and gross (basic) Systems Review, I decided to “jump”
to the Physical Exam.
His bowel sounds were still present. I
lightly palpated his Abdomen, and he winced as I examined his RUQ and
RLQ. I then percussed, and was internally pleased when he felt pain
from this. Omg, Percussion Tenderness is present! He could really
have Appendicitis.
I then gently pressed on the left half
of his Abdomen, which wasn't painful, but I let go after a few
seconds, and he winced again, saying it hurts the right side of his
Abdomen.
OMG he has Rovsing's Sign! I was so
delighted upon seeing this for the first time, but didn't smile about
this in front of the others. I became very excited and concerned.
“I think he has Appendicitis, I need
to tell Karl immediately,” I said.
Karl soon came and I presented the
case, with Appendicitis being my most likely differential, in which
he agreed, and continued him on the empirical antibiotics.
I felt so proud of myself on having
“diagnosed” Appendicitis within 15 minutes, but knew that I had a
hint from Dr. Dan's mini-notes, so could take a targeted history and
physical exam much more easily. If I had no hints to begin with, my
clerking would be more time-consuming, and that will only improve
with practice and feedback. But I was also happy to see in person,
how a patient doesn't necessarily present themselves perfectly as per
the textbook descriptions.
He was monitored overnight and was to
be transferred to the ED of GVNH, for admission to have an
Appendicectomy.
I knew that the overall standards of
Healthcare in Developing countries were lower than in Developed
countries, but it was still shocking to see the differences in
person.
I spoke in my slow, “formal”
English accent to one of the ED Drs, who wrote notes based on what I
said, including Physical Exam findings, including the Rovsing's Sign.
I was surprised. Isn't the ED Dr supposed to examine the Pt himself?!
For some reason, it was another ED Dr
that ended up physically examining Mateus. Ok, at least he's been
examined by someone now. Bloods were to be taken next.
Next was the jaw-dropping moment. The
Dr used a glove to tie around Mateus' arm as the “tourniquet”,
and with his bare hands (unwashed), started inserting the needle into
Mateus' vein. Mateus' arm wasn't even swabbed with Alcohol!!!
Internally, I was gasping and horrified, but still
maintained my Flat Affect on the outside. Oh how I dearly wished to
have taken a photo of the Dr taking Mateus' blood, and get away with
it!!! I'd be very interested in seeing the infection rates from
Venepunctures and Cannulas in East Timorese patients secondary to
poorer hygiene practices.
![]() |
| "The Scream", by Edvard Munch. |
I left after the bloods were taken, as
he then had to wait until 2 PM (it was now ~12:30 PM) to
have an Abdo Ultrasound done as the radiographers were still on their
lunch break. In fact, the
majority of the hospital staff (doctors, nurses, lab staff) have a
lunch break from 12 – 2 PM. Things go to a halt.
It baffled
me as to why GVNH doesn't roster their staff in a way, so there's at
least 1 person working at any time of the day, or that staff take
turns working during lunchtime. I suspect a strong factor was the
near absence of Litigation. Then again, on their relatively “peanut”
wages (apparently ~$US 700 / month for Interns at GVNH), if
the Medico-Legal pressure was present akin to Australia, I bet 90+%
(if not 100%) of the Drs would try to jump ship to another Country,
or another Career altogether. Anyhow I'd hate to be an acutely ill
patient arriving at the ED at 12:05 PM... : S
Note: I visited Mateus a few days later and it turned out he eventually had an Appendicectomy done, and was recovering with no post-op complications (yet?!).
East Timor Medical Elective - Week 4 (Part 3 / 6)
“ENRICO” (?CANCER METASTASES)
I knew I had a “short fuse”, but
forgot to take my afternoon medication one day. I was trying to clerk
a newly admitted patient called “Enrico”, who Dr. Dan
noted had “Abdominal Pain” as his main complaint.
I think when I'm more tired or
sleep-deprived (especially un-medicated), my mind seems to be more
concrete, inflexible, and absent-minded, augmenting my desire to be
very methodical.
I greeted Enrico and starting asking
him about the Abdominal Pain, trying to cover “SOCRATES” (Site,
Onset, Character, Radiation, Alleviating Factors, Time Course,
Exacerbating Factors, Severity) before moving on to other questions.
I asked him if his Abdominal Pain
spread to other parts of his body, he started talking about his
headache and shoulder pain, and how it's so bad. Without realizing
that his headache was important, I thought he was just going off on a
tangent, or not understanding my question. I thought his shoulder
pain was just a plain old Arthritis from his old age, and that his
headache was the bread-and-butter variety. At the time, I thought
that if Dr. Dan didn't write “Headache” or some other medical
complaint in the mini-notes, then it couldn't be serious or worth
focusing on.
I repeated again slowly in Tetum and
gave examples of pain radiation, but then he kept talking about his
headache, how it's so bad. I was still focusing on the Abdominal Pain
and got increasingly annoyed at his diversion from my history taking.
I think I actually asked the same question in various forms up to 5
times (in grammatically correct Tetum), but to little avail. In my
spaced-out, disinhibited state, I thought he was trying to fool
around with me and got a bit angry. The patient opposite Enrico's bed
giggled from my visible frustration, and said I needed more patience.
It was a futile effort trying to get
him to talk any more about the Abdominal Pain, so I just gave up on
the history taking and physically examined him. He had Epigastric
tenderness, so my differentials included Peptic Ulcer Disease and
Pancreatitis (although that was unlikely).
Soon after, I presented my
“incomplete” case to Karl, and he said that another differential
diagnosis would be Stomach Cancer which has metastasized to his
brain, causing a headache. He needed a CT-Brain at GVNH to rule out
any CNS lesions.
OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.
I felt really guilty, that I got
angry/annoyed at someone who didn't deserve it. It made sense now.
Yes, his headache could very well be a sign of something much more
sinister. I realized that there will be times where being too
methodical is actually bad, and you need to know when to change your
strategy. I also realized that Dr. Dan is also human and at times
will miss things too, so I couldn't just depend on his mini-notes as
the core stimuli for history taking. You need to focus on what the
patient says themselves, expand on that, and attempt to fit the
puzzle pieces together to formulate the relevant differentials.
By
dismissing what the patient says based on what other Drs say, it can
sometimes impair your ability to find the right answer. At the very least, in
Australia I'll be documenting to the best of my ability all of the
patient complaints for Medico-Legal reasons, even if I secretly don't
believe them.
Since this episode, I decided to take
my afternoon medication routinely again to improve my alertness and
cognition. I thought that I didn't need it coz I've “crashed”
(sleep attacks etc) in the afternoon a lot less often than in
Australia, but my cognitive impairments (especially after lunch) were
still present even if I didn't fall asleep. I now also take Dr. Dan's
mini-notes as a “partial hint”, but not a definitive summary of
the patient's problems. At the end of the day, you need to know how
to take a History and do a Physical Exam yourself, for the
benefit/convenience of both you and the patient.
East Timor Medical Elective - Week 4 (Part 2 / 6)
“JOAO” (GLOBAL HEART FAILURE,
and PLACEBO EFFECT?)
Monday evening was very sombre by
comparison. I was about to go home at 6 PM, but as per Murphy's Law,
was informed by a nurse that a new patient just arrived to the
Emergency Room.
“Joao” was a boy who came
with his parents, feeling quite short of breath. Karl and Maria were
still busy in their afternoon ward rounds but would soon check him
out. His legs were both swollen with pitting oedema, abdomen and JVP
distended, all from Right Heart Failure. There were crackles in the
bases of his lungs, suggesting Left Heart Failure too. His heart was
already beating very fast. Unfortunately, he had Mitral Stenosis
which was untreated for years, and now we were looking at the end
complications. Dr. Dan already commenced him on a very low dose of
Beta-Blockers to slow down his heart rate, in addition to taking
Frusemide (a diuretic Rx). I was really anxious for him to get rid of
his “excess” fluid as much as possible.
He was already on medication, I
thought. This is a medical emergency, so ABC, ABC. I quickly looked
at his palms and the inside of his mouth. He wasn't cyanosed yet, but
clearly had increased work of breathing. I ran out of the room to get
a pulse oximeter, returned and clipped it to his finger. 94%
saturation, so still ok-ish. Joao and his parents didn't understand
what the pulse oximeter did, so I basically said it shows how much
oxygen is in the blood, and that anything above 90% is still
acceptable. Joao and his parents then became very focused on the
displayed number. But inside, I felt uncomfortable because I wasn't
sure if that number was correct though. It also displayed his pulse
which was completely inaccurate. I was hoping that by focusing on a
number, that it would help quantify his status and calm him down.
I was confident he needed Oxygen for
comfort and asked Joao if he wanted to try it. He immediately said
yes.
I ran to the nurses' room, and brought
back the oxygen tank with a mask. He looked relieved when it arrived,
and I started putting it on him. I tried to switch on the Oxygen Tank
and turned the delivery rate to 6 Litres / minute, but there was a
leak in the delivery device connecting to it, releasing a small “air
stream”. Barely any of the Oxygen was going through the tube.
I felt devastated. Was Murphy's Law
cursing me again? What should I say to him?
I dramatically increased the delivery
rate, and a bit of the Oxygen was now flowing through the tube, with
the “air stream” producing a prominent hiss. Oh dear, lots of
wastage. I asked Joao if he could feel it coming through, and he said
yes, but only a bit.
He looked much calmer now, but inside
I felt guilty. A lot of Oxygen was leaking out and being wasted,
which could've gone to other future patients in Cardio-Respiratory
distress. How far should one go when there are limited resources?
His Oximetry sats was hovering at around 94 or 95%. But how much
Oxygen is he really receiving? I couldn't quantify it, and was
wondering how much of his calmness was from actually receiving
significant Oxygen, or from the placebo effect of looking like he's
receiving a treatment. Calming his parents down would also have
influence on him.
I holding his hands for a few minutes,
and the room was silent apart from the hiss. Karl and Maria soon
arrived, and ceased the Oxygen delivery as it would be unsustainable
at the current delivery rate, rapidly depleting the Oxygen tank. I
offered to lower it to the original 6 Litres / minute, but this was
also considered a bad idea: If Joao wasn't actually receiving the
Oxygen, then wearing the mask would only result in him breathing back
in more Carbon Dioxide, worsening the situation. His Oximetry sats
was still acceptable in room air, but Joao clearly looked more
distressed / upset.
Karl and Maria were medically correct,
but in my mind, I was still anxious. I was using the Oxygen Tank as a
psychological crutch, and obsessed about giving Joao Oxygen. I called
a BPC assistant who also did some device repair, but he was unable to
repair the leak.
There was one more Oxygen tank, but
much heavier. Joao got admitted to the main ward, with that Oxygen
tank placed next to his bed for “comfort”, even though the
attached device also leaked. I felt really sorry for him. No working
Oxygen tanks at BPC tonight.
Please don't die, please don't die,
please don't die.
It was getting dark and I had to
return home. I said bye bye to Joao and his family. That was the last
I saw of him.
At home that night, I realized how
obsessive I was about the Oxygen, and how emotionally “soft” I
was. I felt so bad/sad to see him suffer, and wanted to give the
Oxygen not only to comfort him psychologically, but myself as well. I
wanted to give them the impression that I was doing something, even
though clinically it wasn't doing much, and resources-wise, unviable.
There was an element of selfishness and I felt guilty. I was
being empathetic, but I had the wrong application.
When there are limited medical
resources, you have to be prudent as much as possible. It's always a
challenge to help many people in such a setting, where there's only
so much you can do. There'll be many times where you just have to be
brutal and ration things out (eg opioid analgesia), when in a
developed country, everyone would have far more access to it. You're
not being intentionally mean or cruel, but trying to use resources
wisely based on priority.
In fact, it could be argued that in
the process of “overtreating” 1 Patient, you'd be impairing the
outcomes of many others, which some would consider as even more
selfish. I suppose in Australia, where rationing of this degree has
yet to take place, Drs have far more breadth to order investigations
and prescribe medications to please Patients (demanding or not), in
addition to covering their asses Medico-Legally. At the end of the
day, you are working as a Dr, and not as a “People-Pleaser” (even
if it attracts more referrals and repeat appointments). For the sake
of good Clinical Practice, there'll eventually come a point where you
need to set boundaries and say “No”.
Note: Joao was transferred to GVNH the
next morning, but died several days later. I couldn't get any further
details from the Ward Clerk at GVNH. RIP... : (
East Timor Medical Elective - Week 4 (Part 1 / 6)
Week 4 (22/9/14 – 26/9/14)
DR DAN'S 70TH BIRTHDAY
Monday this week was Dr. Dan's 70th
Birthday. The morning ward rounds proceeded as usual, but when we
arrived at the Malnutrition Ward, there was a surprise! Luisa and
“Livia” (another assistant) started playing a Happy Birthday song
from their radio. There were balloons, and large colourful letters
saying “HAPPY 70TH BIRTHDAY DR DAN” hung across the wall. A table
with the birthday cake and several beers was in the middle of the
room, surrounded by much of the BPC staff.
The ward rounds took a pause. I
thought that Dr. Dan would cry or be very emotional, given that he's
reached a new decade in life, but he smiled and shook hands with
everyone who congratulated him, one by one. It was so cute to see the
little children smiling and reaching up to shake his hand too.
“Amy” (a volunteer Dr) then
presented Dr. Dan her handmade Birthday Card that we all signed. This
was then followed by the cutting of the birthday cake and
distributing of the beers. The room was small, but at that moment
felt cozy, so very “Gemutlichkeit (sp?)/ Gezellig”.
It was a very pleasant start to the
day, and I (selfishly) felt lucky to have my medical elective
coincide with this occasion, along with the BPC 15th
Anniversary on Friday.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




